Archive

Archive for the ‘Uncategorized’ Category

With or Without You – Nautilus File Browser Side Pane

If you are a Gnome Desktop user on Linux and use Nautilus File Manager to browse your files, here’s a handy tip.

When you access your files via the Places menu, (e.g., Places → Home Folder), there are two ways you can view your files (among many other ways, I guess):

  • The file manager window has a browser pane on the left. This pane (also called the Side Pane) provides easy access to your bookmarks, mounted drives, etc. This is my preferred way. Here’s what it looks like:
    File manager with browser pane - Click for full size

    File manager with browser pane
  • The file manager window does not have a browser pane. One of the reasons I am not so comfortable with this is that it opens a new window when you double-click on a folder. Too many windows can result if you are browsing around. And here’s how it looks:
    File manager without browser pane - Click for full size

    File manager without browser pane

It is a matter of personal preference. Since I use Ubuntu extensively, and its default is to show the file manager with the side pane, I am kind of used to it. So when I started working on another computer where the default was without the side pane, I wasn’t very comfortable.

But as it turns out, like with many other customization options on Linux, this was easy to change.

All it takes is to set the configuration key /apps/nautilus/preferences/always_use_browser to be true. There are a couple of ways you can do that.

With the Configuration Editor GUI

You can start the Configuration Editor from the Application → System Tools menu. Or use the gconf-editor command in the Terminal. Once in the Configuration Editor, navigate to the /apps/nautilus/preferences/always_use_browser key in the left side pane:

/apps/nautilus/preferences/always_use_browser key in the Configuration Editor - Click for full size

/apps/nautilus/preferences/always_use_browser key in the Configuration Editor

Check the checkbox to enable the preference.

With gconftool-2 command

Much easier way, for folks who are not so much against the Terminal. Open the Terminal and use this command:

gconftool-2 --set --type=bool /apps/nautilus/preferences/always_use_browser true

So there. And while we are at it, a quick poll, may be?



Tags: , ,

OneConf in Ubuntu 10.10

Now, this is something I am really looking forward to in the upcoming Ubuntu 10.10 release (a.k.a Maverick Meerkat):

Idea is to store the state of your Ubuntu installation in the cloud, so that it can be cloned on some other machine, or used to restore after a brand new installation.

This is especially relevant because of the 6-month release cycle. I’ve spent many hours – if not days – to bring my system back to where I like it to be, after every fresh install. Furthermore, it may encourage folks to do a fresh install (versus an upgrade), thereby avoiding many problems that often arise after an upgrade. This is great for anyone who provides support on the the Ubuntu Forums – or other support avenues.

Another reason I like this is that, features like this truly justify Ubuntu One. Ubuntu One needs more ideas like OneConf to harness its great potential, and distinguish it from the other online storage/file sharing services. Not to mention the value it adds to Ubuntu as a desktop Linux distribution.

Somehow, all this sounds very familiar!

Can’t wait…

Tags: ,

Camcorder to the Web – HD Video on Ubuntu

Problem statement:

Grab HD clips from Sony HDR-HC7 HDV camcorder and convert them to HD videos on the web (Vimeo, YouTube, etc.) fairly easily on Linux – specifically, Ubuntu

I’ve been trying to address this problem for a while now. It has been about a year since I tried last. I remember using Kino and giving Cinelerra a shot. For variety of reasons, I did not like either and I gave up on the effort.

Recently, when Ubuntu 10.04 shipped with PiTiVi as the default video editor, I decided to give it another go. Since I had used OpenShot briefly in Ubuntu 9.10, I thought it would be educational to try both the video editors to accomplish the task. So I created a short sample video in both these editors – embedded below.

I am a video pro by no means. I am just a novice user trying hard to shoot least shaky HD movies and sharing them with family and friends – while not embarrassing myself! So please take my input and opinions with a grain of salt. But at the end of it all, I think I prefer OpenShot – at least for my camcorder, my level of skill and expertise using video editors.

Now that the result is out of the way, here’s the rest of the story…

Workflow

Workflow I would like to set up is simple:

  1. Grab clips from the camcorder
  2. Convert clips to a format the video editor likes (I would rather not, but necessary with some editors)
  3. Import them into the video editor
  4. Edit/mix the clips and compose the video
  5. Export it to desired target

Grabbing clips from the camcorder

This is something I learned from my previous experience with Kino. I use dvgrab to grab clips from the camcorder. Here is the source of the script I use:

Sony HDR-HC7 is an HDV camcorder. As such, the above script grabs the clips in form of a sequence of MPEG-2 transport stream (.m2t) files. I use the -timestamp option so that the names of the files include the time when the video was recorded. I also store the output of this script for later use. It includes useful information about the clips – like the timecode, length of the clip in frames, size of the clip etc. Here’s a sample output:

Using OpenShot

Importing video

One thing I really loved about OpenShot is the fact that it can consume .m2t files! Kino did not, Cinelerra did not, PiTiVi does not. So this is great. It completely eliminates one step in my workflow.

Import function in OpenShot (the big green ‘+’ sign in the toolbar) allows you to add video (my .m2t files), audio and other media files.

Editing video

For a simple video, like the one I created for this experiment, all you need to do is drag the clips into the timeline – the lower part of the interface – and position them to define the sequence of scenes in the movie.

Here are some editing/mixing features of OpenShot I used in the making of the sample video:

  • The razor tool can be used to snip clips at any given position
  • Markers can be added on the timeline to mark significant positions in the timeline
  • Video in a clip can be turned ON or OFF
  • Audio in a clip can be turned ON or OFF
  • Effects like Fade in/Fade out can be applied to individual tracks
  • There are many transitions and effects, which I did not use in the sample video

I did not play with titles, credits or subtitles, so I cannot say much about those features. All in all, you can do some basic editing and mixing really well.

Exporting video

Another thing you got to love is that OpenShot comes with canned export profiles. Profiles have export parameters set to work with DVD, Web (Vimeo, Youtube and the likes) etc. The fact that export to Vimeo-HD and Youtube-HD worked so well, make me feel very optimistic about DVD export – which is going to be my next endeavor.

Here’s a screenshot of the export dialog.

Exporting for Vimeo using OpenShot - Click for full size

Exporting for Vimeo using OpenShot

And finally, here are the videos out of OpenShot, on both Vimeo (exported with Vimeo-HD profile) and Youtube (exported with Youtube-HD profile).

OpenShot Vimeo HD video:

OpenShot Youtube HD video:

Using PiTiVi

Importing video

Like I mentioned, PiTiVi does not consume .m2t files. Apparently, it has the capability, but there’s probably a bug currently, that keeps it from recognizing the files correctly. So there’s hope!

But for now, you must convert the .m2t files into a format that PiTiVi can read. I used ffmpeg to do so. Here’s the command (and its output) I used for .m2t to .mpg conversion:

Converted .mpg files can now be imported and worked with in PiTiVi.

Editing video

Much like OpenShot, PiTiVi allows you to add video, audio and other media files to a project. You then drag the clips in the time line and position them to define the sequence of scenes in the movie.

Here are some editing/mixing features of PiTiVi I used in the making of the sample video:

  • The scissor tool can be used to snip clips at any given position
  • I could only add one marker (the cursor), but I am sure there is a way to add more. I just did not try to find it
  • Instead of Fade In/Out effects or completely turning ON or OFF a clip, PiTiVi allows you to set track levels (brightness for video tracks, volume for audio tracks). The levels can vary through the track depending on the levels in the beginning and the end of track. I think this provides an added level of flexibility. But also, at the same time, makes simple Fade In/Out slightly harder to implement. I like it though
  • Audio from a video track can be separated into an independent track. This, also, I think is a very handy feature

Again, I did not play with titles, credits or subtitles, so I cannot say much about those features. I also did not easily find any transitions or effects, that could be applied to tracks.

I had trouble synchronizing audio and video in PiTiVi (synchronizing the ‘gong’ with dropping of CD sleeve). I was finally able to synchronize the two with a lot of trial-and-error. The one that rendered kind of synchronized (one below) does not actually look synchronized in the preview. The preview in PiTiVi did not seem very accurate.

Exporting video

PiTiVi does not come with canned export profiles. Although I found a way to export to Vimeo-HD on the Vimeo help sites. It is left to the users to do the research. As you might notice though, the audio/video out of PiTiVi is a bit choppy at times. I probably did not get all the export parameters right. But then again, PiTiVi does not make it any easier.

Here’s the screenshot of the export dialog of PiTiVi:

Exporting for Vimeo using PiTiVi - Click for full size

Exporting for Vimeo using PiTiVi

And here is the resulting Video:

Conclusion

I tend to compare video editors in three different categories – Import, Editing and Export. A good video editor should support a wide variety of input formats. It should have a good balance of powerful and easy-to-use editing features. It should export video in formats that can be played flawlessly on popular targets like the Web (Youtube, Vimeo, etc.) and media players (DVD/VCD players, desktop media players, etc.).

At the time of this writing, I think OpenShot trumps in all the three categories.

  • In my case, PiTiVi could not import .m2t files. This added a step in my workflow. Hopefully this is temporary and will be fixed soon
  • PiTiVi has some neat editing features, but lack of transitions and effects shifts the balance in OpenShot’s favor. Also everything you can do in PiTiVi can be achieved in OpenShot to some extent.
  • OpenShot has export profile for popular targets. This is a must for anyone who doesn’t want to get lost in the many gory details of conversion parameters and their optimal values – certainly for me

Looks like the Linux video editor scene is starting to look up. I hope it only gets better from here.

If something I mentioned in this post is inaccurate/wrong, please point it out in the comments. Hope this helps!



Conky with XMMS2 on Ubuntu 10.04 (Lucid Lynx)

Default Conky in Ubuntu 10.04 (Lucid Lynx) does not come with xmms2 support built in. Since I use xmms2 extensively, building conky from source was the only option. Here’s how I did it:

That should install Conky with xmms2 support in /opt/conky. And here’s the obligatory screen shot:

XMMS2 music display with Conky - Click for full size

XMMS2 music display with Conky

Just for reference, here’s the conkyrc I use for music:

Happy listening!

Tags: , ,

Nginx and PHP on Ubuntu Lucid

To do some PHP development (read experimenting) on my laptop I wanted to get a web-server with PHP running on it. Since this is a laptop with limited resources, I decided to try Nginx instead of Apache. Nginx is known to use less memory as compared to Apache. I am hoping this will keep the laptop still usable while the web-server is still running in the background.

This is not an exhaustive how-to, but this is how I installed all that is needed to get my first PHP page up.

Let me begin by mentioning that this laptop currently runs the development build of Ubuntu Lucid (which will become Ubuntu 10.04 LTS sometime in April 2010).

To begin, I installed following packages from Ubuntu Lucid repositories:

  % sudo aptitude install nginx php5-cgi lighttpd

Although I am not using lighttpd, the package is required because it provides the spawn-fcgi script.

Nginx supports FastGI natively. PHP is served as a FastCGI process.

Modify /etc/php5/cgi/php.ini to include the following line:

cgi.fix_pathinfo=1

Setting this configuration makes sure that PHP sets path information of the executing script in a way that conforms with CGI specifications. The line may already exist in the file, but commented. Just un-comment it. This is an optional step (at least in Lucid version of PHP) since the default value of cgi.fix_pathinfo is 1.

To spawn FastCGI add the following line to /etc/rc.local every time the computer starts.

/usr/bin/spawn-fcgi \
    -a 127.0.0.1 -p 9000 -u www-data -g www-data \
    -f /usr/bin/php5-cgi -P /var/run/fastcgi-php.pid

This script (spawn-fcgi) was installed via the lighttpd package.

Finally, I configured a website in Nginx and enabled PHP via FastCGI. This configuration would typically reside in /etc/nginx/sites-available/<website_name>:

server {
  listen   80;
  server_name  localhost;

  access_log  /var/log/nginx/localhost.access.log;

  root   /var/www/blog;
  index  index.php;
  fastcgi_index  index.php;

  #
  # pass the PHP scripts to FastCGI server listening on 127.0.0.1:9000
  #
  location ~ \.php$ {
    fastcgi_pass   127.0.0.1:9000;
    fastcgi_param  SCRIPT_FILENAME  $document_root$fastcgi_script_name;
    include /etc/nginx/fastcgi_params;
  }
}

When all is set up properly, you can test it with the phpinfo() command. It should look something like the following:

phpinfo() screen - Click for full size

phpinfo() screen with Nginx+PHP setup

All this, mostly a note to self. But hope it helps someone out there.

Tags: , , ,

Personas built into Firefox 3.6?!

So Firefox 3.6 was released recently, it has some nice features.

In the list, there’s one feature addition that bothers me – default support for Personas. This is not exactly a new feature, it has been around as a Mozilla Labs project.

I usually stick with the default theme of any application I use. It is the one that developers have put most effort in. But just for kicks, I have tried out Personas in the past. Each time, it did not last more than a few hours before I uninstalled it.

In my opinion, Personas – no matter how popular, or highly rated they are – mess up the readability of Firefox window. I am sure it is a great distraction for people who spend most of their time playing with themes. But isn’t that why there are extensions/add-ons? If someone is so inclined, install the Personas add-on and you are all set to hurt your eyes!

Here, you be the judge:

Firefox with one of the popular personas

Firefox with one of the popular Persona themes, hurts my eyes! (click to enlarge)

That is Firefox with one of the more popular Personas. And here is Firefox with it’s default theme:

Firefox with the default theme

Firefox with its default theme is much more readable… (click to enlarge)

Not sure about you, but I’d stick with the default theme.

But hey! no one is grabbing me by the collar and forcing me to use Personas. So it’s all good.

Only thing I am curious about is the thinking behind picking the Personas Labs project to be integrated into Firefox. Why not Prizm? Or Weave, that would be awesome! Or Ubiquity perhaps. All these add value to Firefox too. May be they all have the merit, but are not mature enough?

I hope Personas was not picked because Google Chrome has a developing themes ecosystem… (and bunch of folks claiming ‘Oh! look how cool my Chrome looks’).

Granted that Personas is still a work in progress (it does not theme buttons and icons, like actual themes do), and that it is a better way to implement themes. But in the end, I still maintain that Personas was great as an add-on, and it should have stayed that way.

With rants and opinions out of the way, what is your favorite Firefox 3.6 feature?



Blog Scare and Chrome OS Update

Today I had a kind of a scare. This morning, I noticed that this blog was down. My first guess was that it should probably be related to the intermittent outages my host was facing.

The blog was sending back 500 – Internal Server Error responses. The error.log file was filled with messages like these:

[Tue Nov 24 10:38:42 2009] [error] [client 149.117.7.28] Premature end of script headers: index.php
[Tue Nov 24 10:39:23 2009] [error] [client 149.117.7.28] Premature end of script headers: index.php
[Tue Nov 24 10:41:05 2009] [error] [client 209.85.238.214] Premature end of script headers: index.php
[Tue Nov 24 10:41:46 2009] [error] [client 209.85.238.214] Premature end of script headers: index.php

As usual, I looked for help on the WordPress Forums. When the initial suggestions did not resolve the problem, I decided to dig deeper. I downloaded WordPress and extracted a clean install. All I did was moved over this blog’s wp-config.php into this directory. It again resulted in the same 500 – Internal Server Error response. That almost certainly indicated a corrupt database.

Thankfully, reverting to the last good backup is fairly easy in DreamHost Panel. The Restore DB option is available under Actions for each database in the Main Menu → MySQL Databases section of the panel. After restoring the database, the blog was back up and running.

Now, only thing bothering me is – what caused the database corruption? Was it some server glitch, that would hopefully never happen again? Was it a plugin (like IntenseDebate, etc.) that misbehaved? Or a blog management client (like WordPress for BlackBerry, etc.)? Not sure. But the mystery does make me nervous. But for the time being, things look OK!

Chrome OS Update

In my last post about running Chrome OS in VirtualBox, there are some screenshots. As you can see, the default screen size of 800x600 is pretty tiny to do anything useful.

To increase the screen size, I tried two ways I would have tried for any other Linux guest:

Not sure why, but I could not install any Guest Additions to the Chrome OS running as guest.

I tried to update /etc/X11/xorg.conf to define screen modes (by first dropping to a shell using ALT + CTRL + t – which, by the way, does not always work for me :( ). But Chrome OS would not let me save the /etc/X11/xorg.conf, even with sudo. Is this normal?

In any case, I had to take the long route. Updating ~/chromiumos/src/rootfs_static_data/common/etc/X11/xorg.conf and re-building the image. But it worked! Now I am running Chrome OS in 1024x768 mode, which is so much better!

Chromium OS in VirtualBox in 1024x768 mode

Chromium OS build in VirtualBox, running Google Wave is so much better at 1024×768

That is it for now…

Chrome OS in VirtualBox

Ever since they made the Chromium source code public yesterday morning, I’ve been itching to build it and take it for a spin. I did not know it would take only a couple hours to do that!

Getting and Building

I am so impressed! The instructions on the Getting and Building a Chromium-Based OS page are precise, to-the-point and.. they work! I am not sure if this is brilliant scripting, great documentation, me having just right prerequisites (Ubuntu Karmic Koala), or a combination of all these. But it took me just over an hour or so to download source and build a ‘.vmdk‘ file for VirtualBox. I did not see that coming.

I’ve built other projects from source before. It always involves some figuring-out. Sometimes the documentation is not adequate – may be inadequate for my skill-set. Sometimes the prerequisites are not clearly specified/checked. Building an entire OS, I was preparing for a few days of reading up and figuring things out.

But it was none of that. I just followed the steps – mostly word-to-word – and I had a virtual disk image (.vmdk file) at the end of it all!

The only change I had to do was to BASE_FROM in ~/chromiumos/src/platform/chrome/copy_chrome_zip.sh to use build.chormium.org instead of chrome-web. I think this was because I chose not to build Chromium (browser) from source. I am sure this will be ironed out soon (may be it is already).

Using in VirtualBox

I followed the instructions to Convert the image for VMWare, which creates a .vmdk file. Instead of using VMWare workstation, I used VirtualBox to fire it up.

Impressions

I love the concept of Google Chrome OS. I think it is very relevant to how we use the computer these days. It would be even better if Chrome OS would coexist with a normal OS on any laptop. I agree that most often we only use the computer to access the web and do most of our things on the Internet. But I am not ready to give up the full-fledged OS, not quite yet. Does that remind me of SplashTop?

Here are a couple of obligatory screenshots:

Woo hoo! Build worked!

Chromium OS build in VirtualBox, running Google Wave

Following is the list of Apps currently on the home page. These showed up only today. Yesterday when I was trying the OS for the first time, one could only use @google.com usernames to sign in. I am sure things are going to be changing fast in the next weeks/months.

Apps on Chromium OS home page

Apps on Chromium OS home page

Next…

Next thing I am going to try is to get hold of a 4GB USB drive and see if this image works on my laptop.

Secondly, I am curious to see if the OS updates itself in the VirtualBox, like Google has mentioned. If it does, I should not be required to build another image… ever!

Back to more experiments.

Later…

Koalas are in!

It’s been around a week since Ubuntu 9.10 – Karmic Koala was released. Both my Linux systems are now up-to-date.

Linux systems

One of the two machines is a Sony Vaio Laptop (VGN-T140P) and other is a desktop built on a Asus P5K-e Wifi/AP motherboard with an Nvidia 8400GS video card.

Install strategy

In both cases I chose to do a clean install. I always keep /home on a separate partition, so clean installs are not much of a hassle. I usually move all the dot-files (and directories) from /home/me out of the way before a clean install. After the install, I bring the ones I need manually. This, I believe, prevents any configuration issues arising from new versions of applications adding/removing/changing any configuration items. I do have to configure some applications – like compiz – all over again, but it is not a big deal most of the time.

I also make a copy of /etc directory before a clean install, just in case I need to refer to the hacks that worked around bugs in the previous release.

Trends

If I look at the way thinks are working on the two of my systems since Ubuntu 8.10 – Hardy Heron, I see pretty consistent trends. My laptop was at its best in Hardy, things are not quite that good now. The desktop, however, is at its best in Karmic! I wonder if it has to do with the video hardware (Intel in laptop, Nvidia in desktop) or wireless usage (I use it in laptop all the time, never on the desktop).

Suspend/resume has gotten worse on the laptop, but almost perfect on the desktop.

Laptop is plagued with wireless issues, but I know I am not alone there (Launchpad bug reports as of today).

Sound, at least on my systems, has greatly improved. It worked out of the box on both of them.

Laptop experience

The general feel of the OS has definitely improved. With the new boot experience, artwork, new themes, Karmic looks pretty neat. It is snappier than ever, even on the laptop with mediocre specifications. All that good stuff is marred by the issues that have come up in this release – from back in the alpha days.

There has always been a problem with the laptop hardware, that when it resumes from suspend (to RAM), the backlight is missing. In the past, I have been able to work around it by setting quirks in suspend/resume scripts. Those hacks don’t work anymore. I haven’t found any work-around for Karmic yet. Launchpad bug #417599.

An even worse issue that has come up is with the wireless networking. In my case, it just doesn’t connect. Even when it does, it doesn’t stay connected for long. It is extremely annoying. Launchpad but #429035. So its mostly wired network for now. I know, laptop wired to the router? That sucks :(
I hope not for very long though.

Desktop experience

On the desktop, Karmic is just sweet. Out of the box, everything just worked. Sound, video, suspend/resume, everything!

The only thing worth mentioning is that when I first rebooted the system after installing Karmic, Windows entry was missing from the Grub2 menu. All I did to fix this was:

  % sudo update-grub

I wonder why it missed the Windows entry during installation. I am sure it runs update-grub as an installation step, doesn’t it? In any case, if you see Windows entry missing from your Grub menu after installing Karmic on a dual-boot machine, just run the above command.

One more thing I haven’t checked is if wake-on-lan works. If it doesn’t I’ll need to do what I usually do after clean Ubuntu installs – Howto: Wake on LAN with ASUS P5WDG2 WS Pro in Debian/Ubuntu. Hope it works this time too!

Well, there. Now that the computer are all working, time to get some work done!

Incidentally, I set up a github account for all my little hobby projects. Check it out. All the projects are purely experimental and educational. Nothing is going to blow your mind.

Tags: , ,

Opera Mini 5 Beta on BlackBerry Pearl

I’ve been using the next generation of Opera Mini browser – Opera Mini 5 beta – on my BlackBerry Pearl.

In a nutshell – in comparison with Opera Mini 4 – it looks slick, but usability sucks!

It is almost sacrilegious to comment on the quality of a Beta product, but I couldn’t find a way to pass on my feedback to Opera directly (comment, if you know how). May be folks at Opera haven’t tested this version with BlackBerry Pearl. May be the Pearl is just too old. But here is what’s been bothering me last few days:

Keyboard Shortcuts

I don’t know about others, but I use keyboard shortcuts extensively with Opera Mini. To access speed dial entries, to refresh, to go to bookmarks, etc.

In Mini 4, it was as easy as hitting * n to access speed dial entry n (e.g., * 1 for speed dial 1, * 2 for speed dial 2, etc.).

In Mini 5 beta, the ALT key must be used to use a symbol or number. So the keyboard not-so-shortcut to access speed dial entry n becomes ALT * ALT n (e.g., ALT * ALT 1 for speed dial 1, ALT * ALT 2 for speed dial 2, etc.). A little annoying!

Typing

The Inline Editing feature in Mini 5 beta allows you to use the multi-tap input method to edit text-box entries on web pages. I prefer using the SureType input method. So I turned off the Inline Editing feature.

Even without Inline Editing, the text box entries are edited right on the web page. Mini 4 would open a text entry dialog of a sort to edit text. This is cool!

Scrolling

Now this could be just that my Pearl is too old for the new generation of software, it doesn’t have enough resources to handle them. But scrolling performance is really poor. Every scrolling movement results in the hourglass (processor busy). I have a feeling that it still accepts trackball inputs while it is busy, though. Because when the hourglass is gone, its scrolls way too much. I must scroll back to get where I want to – which of course means another few seconds of hourglass.

This is not an issue in Mini 4.

Mobile view

Staying on the scrolling topic, what happened to the fast scrolling in mobile view by moving the trackball horizontally? That was so handy! In Mini 5, the mouse pointer is always visible. So moving the trackball horizontally only moves the pointer.

I loved how Mini 4 would go to next link or page down/up by moving the trackball vertically and scroll fast by moving it horizontally.

For now, I am just trying to get used to keyboard navigation. It results in a slightly better performance.

Fonts

Mini 4 fonts were almost perfect sized for me. Mini 5 beta fonts are either too big, or too small. In my settings, I’ve set the font size to medium. Which makes fonts a little bigger than what Mini 4 had. I guess I’ll get used to them.

However, the fonts on Mini 5 beta’s menu and other interface are a little too small. Wonder how to change them, I am sure there is a way.

All in all, I think Mini 5 beta is a neat looking browser for the phone, but seems a little resource hungry, which in case of an older phone like the Pearl is a problem. Most of the new features are targeted towards touchscreen devices and don’t apply to Pearl.

What’s been your experience?